On dropping positive judgement

“How did I fail to see it?” I asked a friend recently.
“We need to see things As They Are, not As We Want Them To be,” she replied.

Later that week, I was given one of those brainteasers where you have to join the dots using a limited number of lines. You’ve probably seen it. If you haven’t, it’s pretty simple: just join the dots using no more than FOUR straight lines, without lifting your pen from the page:

I had seen it before, but it was fun to see the other people given the brainteaser struggle with the field of dots in front of them. The field implies a shape, but the implied shape is not actually there. The brain imposes a familiar shape, and the familiar shape prevents you from seeing the other possibilities. (Out of interest, there is more than one feasible solution.)

Of course, the notion of a paradigm shift, of “thinking out of the box” is not unfamiliar to most of us. I’ve seen this exercise (and many like it), I thought. I’ve facilitated workshops of my own where I’ve given this very exercise to other people. It illustrates terribly nicely how our own pre-existing assumptions limit our ability to solve utterly soluble problems. Don’t impose judgements. See what is there, not what you think you see. Yeah yeah yeah. We’ve all heard it before. I already know this stuff, I thought. But then it occurred to me that all I was doing now was the same thing, dressed in a new guise. The revised value judgement? The familiar is of less value than the unfamiliar. I’d seen it before, therefore it had nothing to show me.

Is this so? What happens when we overlook the familiar simply because it is familiar?

The work of cultivating awareness is largely the work of listening carefully, paying careful attention. Labelling situations or events as positive or negative is, in a sense, a way of washing over the reality with value judgement. I like it – so I see it through the gleaming pretty wash of my own preference. I don’t like it – so I see it through the dark, distorting colours of my own dislike. Both positive and negative judgements are a distortion. The opposite of the voice of judgement is not the sweet voice of love and appreciation. The opposite of the voice of judgement is attentive, receptive silence. And writing off the familiar is simply another, insidious face of our tendency of not seeing what’s in front of us.

All too often, in the literature and encounters of self-development, we hear the injunction to “drop judgement”, to “listen unjudgementally.” But all too often, that becomes code for “be positive and appreciative”; applaud everyone. We particularly welcome and respond to the familiar. I identify with your story; you must be just like me; I have empathy for you. I do not identify at all with your story; you are so different from me; we have nothing in common; I cannot empathise at all. Identifying positively with others is not evidence of non-judgement at all. In fact, it is often the hallmark of yet more judgement – although it’s the kind of judgement that we find comforting and enjoyable to entertain.

But what is the point of dropping judgements if they are fun and enjoyable? Why not simply delight in positive identification when it coes up?

The point is that positive judgement is no less destructive than negative judgement, it’s just more insidious. We live in a society where we are trained from an early age to perform for approval. I see it with my little boy, who is constantly told how “good” he is. “Good” being code for quiet, well-behaved, convenient for others. Crying is “naughty”; quietness is “good”. This is where it starts. Later it will graduate towards enforcing being “nice”, being “polite”, doing what “you’re supposed to”… And how many of us have had to unlearn this coded, deeply internalised judgement in years and years of therapy? And how many more of us live lives fraught and unhappy, locked beneath a facade of doing what they think they should do, with people they should like, partners they should love, when underneath it they don’t? Living a little more authentically than that – that is the point of dropping the judgements.

It is constant work, this work of awareness. Wishing you all a week – or a day, or perhaps just a moment – of seeing things As They Are.


About Lisa

I live in South Africa with my husband and two small children, doing things, thinking about things and sometimes writing about them.
This entry was posted in awareness, family and friends, relationships and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to On dropping positive judgement

  1. Tom Cox says:

    When did the notion of judging something gain such negative connotations anyway? I agree it has it’s danger’s whether it’s positive or negative judgment, but at the end of the day I find the idea of going with out judgment positively scary and infact rather silly… the trick is not holding on to ones judgements too firmly

  2. Lara says:

    this is a lovely piece, and wortht re-reading.
    I think we need to ne wary of judgement because it happens to soon, and cuts off the other possibilities – people judge and then SHUT DOWN their thinking on the matter because they’re reached a decision. Judgement of a kind is needed, but i guess we need the kind that follows openness and respects its own limitations and above all is subject to self-review and can be cast aside without loss of face when the situation changes. And that’s a hard part, for me.
    And YES YES YES to the good baby syndrome .. I resisted it from the beginning, but its EVERYWHERE .. and as they grow you have to think carefully about what to praise. Boys, for example, are never praised for looking pretty or making an effort with their appearance .. what a shame, when you look at some adult men 🙂
    I’d love to hear more of your thoughts on lots of these things.

  3. Lara says:

    ooops, one million typos .. sorry.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s